Buggy's fruit gets the cleanest possible fit between mimetic root and super-power — バラバラ doesn't need reinterpreting the way ゴムゴム or ハナハナ do, because "scattered/in pieces" already describes a body split into floating parts with no editorializing required. The reveal panel plays that literalness for both horror and comedy at once: Zoro's shocked "手が......!!浮いてやがる......!!!" ("The hand... it's floating!") lands one beat before Buggy's own name-drop, so the reader gets the visual gag and the vocabulary word in the same breath, on the same page (Vol. 2, p.57).

Where Gum-Gum is this dictionary's control group for translation discipline, Chop-Chop is the counter-example. The corpus catches VIZ rendering the identical Japanese attack name two different ways within three pages of each other: バラバラ砲 becomes "CHOP-CHOP CANNON!" at Vol. 2, p.64 but "CHOP-CHOP HARPOON!!!!" at Vol. 3, p.18 — same weapon-suffix compound, two different English weapons. The very next chapter repeats the pattern: バラバラ緊急脱出っ!! is "CHOP-CHOP QUICK DODGE!!" on Vol. 3, p.15 and "CHOP-CHOP QUICK ESCAPE!!" on Vol. 3, p.24 — the same emergency maneuver named twice, translated twice, with no attempt at internal consistency even a few pages apart. Early-arc Buggy fights generate a lot of one-off named attacks fast, and it shows in the seams.

The fruit's own base name isn't immune either. An SBS reader-mail answer at Vol. 6, p.104 — cataloguing known Devil Fruits alongside Luffy's — calls it the "Scatter-Scatter fruit," abandoning "Chop-Chop" for a more literal gloss of バラバラ even though the main story had already locked in "Chop-Chop" four volumes earlier. It's a small crack, but a real one: readers following only the SBS extras would meet two different English names for the same fruit before Volume 6 ends. None of that undercuts the reveal scene itself, which stays sharp regardless of translator — "THE CHOP-CHOP FRUIT...!!!" hits with the same clean shock in English as バラバラの実.....!!! does in Japanese, precisely because the underlying word was never obscure to begin with.